| Alexander Wilson, 1856-1858 ; 1862-1868 DDGM - 1861-64 High Priest - Midland Chapter 1869-72 |
Walter J. Seeley, 1924 | Ralph C. Haynes, 1964 |
| Silas R. Martine, 1859 | John M. Gaynor, 1925 DDGM 1930 |
William H. Reed, 1965 * |
| Joshua Draper, 1860 | Harold W. Mailler, 1926 | Martin Ercoline, 1966 |
| John G. Wilkin, 1861 | Howard W. Weale, 1927 | Laurence Tweksbury, 1967 |
| Albert H. Corwin, 1869-1871 | Rainey S. Taylor, 1928 | Jacob Schloss, 1968 |
| Moses D. Stivers, 1872 | Fred J. Hodge, 1929 Sec. Hoffman Lodge 1930-46 |
Robert S. Murray, 1969 |
| Willis L. Bagley, 1873-1876 DDGM - 1880 High Priest - Midland Chapter 1878-80 |
William B. Cornelius, 1930 Sec. Hoffman Lodge 1947-50 Worthy Patron - Queen Esther Chapter 1946-48, 50 |
Alexander M. Hogg, 1970 |
| Moses H. Van Keuren, 1877-78 | Franklin H. Kramer, 1931 DDGM 1946 |
Roy I. Hutchings, 1971 |
| Theron N. Little, 1879-1882 | Edward White, 1932 High Priest - Midland Chapter 1938 Commander KT 1941 |
Frederick M. Baker, 1972 |
| Charles V. Puff, 1881 | John H. Arfmann, 1933 | Kermit W. Lewis, 1973 |
| Amos D. Seaman, 1883-1884 | R. Edgar Clarke, 1934 | Richard A. Hutchings, 1974 * |
| Samuel G. Beyea, 1885-1886 | Janes E. Lyon, 1935 High Priest - Midland Chapter 1929 |
Charles E. Stewart, Sr., 1975 * |
| Samuel M. Boyd, 1887-1890 | Edward T. Van Gorder, 1936 | John Gordon Smith, 1976 DDGM O-R District, 1981 |
| John A. Wallace, 1891-1892 High Priest - Midland Chapter 1884-85 |
E. Laverne Peck, 1937 | Franklin W. Redner, 1977 * |
| Wilbur M. Combs, 1893-1894 DDGM - 1895 |
Clarence E. Worden, 1938 | Albert Bruno, 1978 * |
| Julius F. Korn, 1895 | Philip Van Keuren, 1939 Worthy Patron - Queen Esther Chapter 1941, 44, 49, 51 |
Milton L. Kuhlman, 1979 |
| Henry C. Corwin, 1896 | Charles H. Borland, 1940 | R. Barry McPhillips, 1980 |
| Ira L. Case, 1897-1898 High Priest - Midland Chapter 1881-83, 88, 90-92 |
Clarence E. Wilson, 1941 | George P. Tingus, 1981 |
| Jeremiah, E. Barnes, 1899-1900 | Charles W. Hess, 1942 | Allan D. Ackerson, 1982 * |
| Eugene B. Quick, 1901 | George J. Tischner, 1943 | Dean W. Connell, 1983 * |
| William H. Biggin, 1902 Worthy Patron - Queen Esther Chapter 1898-1900 |
Harold M. Birdsall, 1944 Commander KT 1936 |
William C. Robacker, 1984 * TPM - Valley of Middletown LOP |
| Moses A. Stivers, 1903 | Alton F. Bradner, 1945 Worthy Patron - Queen Esther Chapter 1954 Asst. Grand Lecturer 1955 Grand Sword Bearer 1964 |
Charles W. Smith, 1985 * DDGM O/R District |
| Isodor Budwig, 1904-1905 Worthy Patron - Queen Esther Chapter 1903 |
Earl W. Jacobson, 1946 | Paul G. DiMaggio, 1986 * |
| Nathan D. Mills, 1906-1907 DDGM 1911 |
Stuart L. Wright, 1947 | John N. Nattress, 1987 * |
| John H. Galloway, 1908 Commander, KT 1915-16 |
Frank M. Sears, 1948 Sec. Hoffman Lodge 1951 |
William C. Cuddy, 1988 * |
| Burton L. La Mont, 1909 | James E. Evans, 1949 | Bernard M. Levy, 1989; 1997 * |
| Delbert D. Townsend, 1910 Asst. Grand Lecturer 1911 |
Elwood A. Thorn, 1950 | Rudey S. Levey, 1990 |
| Fred B. Williams, 1911 | Richard M. Gregory, 1951 | Charles D. Vandemark, 1992 * |
| Warren J. Adams, 1912 | Richard H. Morse, 1952 | Richard A. Heip, 1993 * |
| John Bright, 1913 DDGM 1921 |
Clarence V. Seeley, 1953 DDGM O/R District 1957 |
Don L. Bates IV, 1994; 1999 * |
| J. Harry Ward, 1914 | Russell S. Gowdey, 1954 | Harrison W. Keesler, 1995 * |
| Harry T. Crist, 1915 | Raymond E. Sherwood, 1955 | Richard G. Bull, 1996; 1998 |
| Irving W. Davey, 1916 Asst. Grand Lecturer 1921 |
Joseph A. Groh, 1956 | William J. Fitzhenry, 2000 - 2005* |
| J. Noble Wood, 1917 | Edwin L. Starbuck, 1957 | Alfred H. Denninger, 2005-2006 * President - O-RDMA 2003-2004 TPM - Valley of Middletown LOP 2003-2004 |
| Charles H. Pickard, 1918 | Robert Taylor, 1958 | Eugene McGill, 2006-2008 * |
| Fred S. Rogers, 1919 | Henry A. Itzla, 1959 | |
| Charles E. Taylor, 1920 | William Speirs, 1960 Asst. Grand Lecturer O-R District, 1968-1969 DDGM, 1972 |
|
| Frank T. Chambers, 1921 Asst. Grand Lecturer 1930 |
Meyer Miller, 1961 | |
| Harmon F. Mentley, 1922 Commander KT 1933 |
Rodney Martin, Jr., 1962 | |
| Thomas C. Rogers, 1923 | Samuel Warycka, 1963 * |